American economy teaches
lessons
Matthew Caster
The recent collapse of energy-trading giant
Enron poses some serious questions to all Americans. Many people are asking
whether the current
presidential administration was involved.
Others question the current system under which corporations are permitted
to make campaign
contributions to political candidates.
Still others are pondering potential new names for Enron Field.
What is really of concern is what FoxNews.com
referred to as the "Enron Effect." Is the biggest bankruptcy in American
history going to have the
same sweeping effect on corporate America
as the tragedy of Sept. 11 had on personal privacy issues? In other words,
will the freedoms of
corporations to conduct business be subjugated
by the American government?
To put these questions aside, it's time
for a lesson in democratic capitalism. "Democracy" is what politicians
call the government of the United
States when they want us, the people,
to think we have power. "Capitalism" is what politicians call the mode
of our economy right before they
regulate it.
Perhaps one of the niftiest things about
capitalism is the parity between success and failure. Eighteenth-century
economic genius Adam Smith
said a capitalistic economy would be regulated
not by the government, but by the "invisible hand" of competition. Sell
a superior item at a superior
price, and success is likely. But Smith
also alluded to something called "business ethics," which appears to be
where Enron fell through.
The point is, in a capitalistic society
such as ours, businesses either succeed or fail based on how they conduct
themselves. Though the financial
hardships thrust upon the employees of
Enron are unfortunate, the company itself got what it deserved. There is
no honor in lying to investors,
and it is foolish that companies even
allow these questionable accounting techniques to be used.
Now what should the government do to help
out these poor employees? Not a blessed thing. The collapse of Enron was
undoubtedly the fault of
upper-level management. But the reason
so many lost their life savings was, quite simply, because they were poor
investors.
Aesop warned 2,500 years ago, "Don't put
all your eggs in one basket." Apparently, the message was lost on Enron's
employees. Those who
would choose to invest their entire life
savings in one company hardly even deserve pity, let alone government aid
outside the realm of
unemployment benefits.
However, the Rev. Jesse Jackson, in an
attempt to take the spotlight off his illegitimate child, has rallied former
employees into thinking the
government owes them for Enron's collapse.
What nerve. How does one approach the government
and ask for money in this situation? "Hey, Uncle Sam? Yeah, I was a complete
idiot and
invested my entire life savings in a company
that just went bankrupt. Any chance you'd care to bail me out?"
That is the supreme triumph of laziness
and stupidity. Wouldn't it be wonderful if the government reimbursed every
American who lost money in
the stock market? No. Neither the companies
themselves nor the government would survive if it were equally profitable
whether a stock went up
or down. Since when has it become a policy
to reward people for foolish investments? I sympathize with their plight,
but these people don't
deserve to see a dime.
The government is talking about placing
strict regulations on 401(k) retirement plans and the way corporations
can control them. While the
intentions behind this legislation are
well placed, the only thing it will do is provide investors with a false
sense of security. Businesses can still
fail, and if investors don't realize that,
this debacle will only be repeated.
The biggest lesson everyone must learn
from the Enron collapse is that this is still a free-market economy where
companies occasionally go
under. By investing a little time and
effort into safeguarding our own nest egg, this sort of situation can be
easily avoided. Some are content to let
the government tell them where to put
their money. Perhaps these folks have forgotten some of the other worthwhile
projects the government
spends our money on.
This country is an economic powerhouse
because of one word: freedom. Let's try and keep it that way. God bless
America.
Caster, a senior chemical engineering
major, can be reached at patrioticcatmaster@yahoo.com.